Welcome to TriRig.com

TorHans Aero 20 Review
article & images by Nick Salazar
Nov 14, 2011  hits 53,685

A Better Bottle
The TorHans Aero 20 bottle

I've said it before - I like to keep the hydration picture simple. I typically run a standard bottle cage between my arms, and I'm happy to tinker with custom bottle/straw setups to get what I consider to be a good solution for my purposes. So that's often what I recommend, because it's what I like. But my logic fails to take into consideration one key fact: not everyone likes to tinker as much as I do. Many athletes want a good, turn-key solution that doesn't require any fiddling, customization, or much effort at all. These athletes have often turned to the standard aero bottle as their hydration solution of choice. And looking around at some of the fastest riders in Kona, you can see that this solution is a popular one. But traditionally, these bottles haven't been designed with a rigorous look at the aerodynamics involved. That is, until TorHans stepped up to bat.

I asked TorHans about the aerodynamics of their bottle, and they responded with a very interesting, thorough wind tunnel test that they used when validating their product. I've made that available for download right here. Their testing protocol is well-described, and actually does seem very fair. A single test bike was rigged up, and a set of static dummy arms was placed on the bike to simulate the real-world conditions of riding. TorHans tested a large battery of products at yaw sweeps from 0 to 15 degrees (one side only), which is a complete enough picture for me. The only downside is that they chose to present their data as single points (an average of all yaw angles), instead of a two-dimensional plot which would give a more complete picture of the situation. Nevertheless, if you believe their results, then their Aero 20 and Aero 30 are very good solutions, and faster than their competitors.

Critique

This Mr. Arms dummy was the TorHans wind tunnel setup. Looks like a great way to get repeatable results.

Of course, any look at a wind tunnel test is best tempered by a healthy dose of criticism. And although I do find the test generally good, I have two potential quibbles. The first is that the test bike TorHans used had a significant amount of spacers above the head tube. Potentially, the Aero 20's good aero shape helped fair that stack of spacers, and I wonder if the results would change on a bike using no spacers. That's the old argument that modern bikes have such carefully-sculpted head tubes that anything in front of them will mess things up. However, that's impossible to know without another battery of tests, and at some point, you just have to draw the line of practicality. TorHans has said they would actually expect even better results on a bike without spacers. In fairness, I can see where that claim might be true - looking at the bottle head-on, it flows very well with the overall shape of the bike, and presents only a tiny frontal profile. The bulk of the bottle sits between the arms anyway, and so is shielded by the hands.

My other concern is in regards to the hand position of the dummy arms. They're in a significantly "scooped" orientation, rather than wrapping around the front of the shifters. Most testers have reported that a between-the-arms bottle actually reduces drag, that is, it should show up as negative on the TorHans plot. But TorHans still found it had 16 grams of drag, and I speculate that may be on account of the dummy's hand position.

Regardless of my qualms, which are most relevant to comparing the TorHans to a BTA bottle, their product appears to be significantly better than its direct competition, notably the Profile Design Aerodrink. My nitpicks regarding the testing probably wouldn't change the TorHans' superior results against those products. But I'm not an aerodynamicist, so take my speculation with a grain of salt as well.

With all the science out of the way, it's a good idea to talk about how the product actually works. Hit the jump for my testing experience with the TorHans Aero 20.


Tags » hydration,  torhans
  • The TorHans Aero 20 is a simple, effective, and well-thought-out solution to triathlon hydration.
  • The Aero Mount Bracket cradles the bottle while riding - you just snap it in, and tighten it down with a strap across the front.
  • The Aero Mount bracket is easy to install - just one zip tie on each side, and it adjusts to fit the width of most aerobars.
  • Even on super skinny bikes with no spacers, the TorHans doesn't take up much space at all.
  • The Aero Tray behind the bottle makes a great place to put a computer, and the minimal refill cap is simple but quite effective.
  • Even the straw gets the aero treatment, and the mast helps keep it in place without resorting to a super sharp, rigid straw.
  • This is how TorHans tested all their equipment - it's a set of dummy arms that makes for very repeatable tests.  Although if I'm nitpicking, I'll say that I don't think his hands are optimally positioned - I think it's usually best to wrap hands around the front of the shifters.
  • The TorHans wind tunnel results.

Related Articles
The number of legitimate hydration options for triathletes has exploded in the last 2 years or so, so much that it's become ripe for a real survey-type article. This is our 2014 BTA Hydration Shootout.
Carbonsmith Glen Alden has come up with a sleek little BTA solution to take the headache out of mounting a bottle between the arms.
Koala has made a novel bottle and cage system with magnetic retention. They asked me to review it, and said I'd love its BTA applications. How'd it measure up?
Possibly my favorite BTA product to date. Profile Design is really stepping up its game.
Michael and Amanda Lovato gave us an exclusive tour inside their garage/training center, and we profiled their several posh Kestrel 4000 rigs.

comments powered by Disqus